Sephora’s stores are stocked with countless options when it comes to eyeshadow palettes — there’s something for practically every kind of beauty aesthetic, from makeup maximalist to a more subtle sensibility. But even with a wealth of products to choose from, there are still some palettes that’ve managed to rise in popularity far more than others, outlasting the competition to reach cult-fave status.

We looked through hundreds of eyeshadow palettes at Sephora, read the reviews, and picked out best neutral single eyeshadow, best neutral eyeshadow palette 2019, and best neutral eyeshadow palette at sephora options to fit any style from sparkly to subtle. Whether you’re looking for all the colors of the rainbow, or firmly standing in team neutral, there’s an eyeshadow palette in this list to befriend this summer — and for an affordable price point, too.

best neutral eyeshadow palette at sephora

The City Mini Eye Shadow Palette

Look glam on the go with Maybelline New York’s pigmented and affordable The City Mini Eye Shadow Palette. “[The color scheme] Diamond District is one of my favorites because it has a couple of beautiful neutrals…with a universal shimmer that looks great paired with any color, and some fun pops of color to elevate any look,” says New York City-based makeup artist Amrita Mehta. This versatile palette can easily be used for a subtle look or dramatic smoky eye. “I love using the shades with a wet angle brush as a liner or a fluffy brush for a beautiful wash of color,” adds Mehta.

Prados Beauty The Matriarch Eyeshadow Palette

Prados Beauty’s The Matriarch Eye Shadow Palette is truly wearable art. The brand partnered with artist Steven Paul Judd on this palette filled with 30 deep and vibrant shades of pinks, blues, greens, and more. Los Angeles-based makeup artist Robin Black says, “It’s long-lasting, easy to apply, and has a fun range of colors — plus, you can feel good about supporting an inspiring brand.” Prados Beauty’s overall mission? To give back to fellow indigenous communities.

Makeup by Mario Master Mattes Eye Shadow Palette

“This palette basically covers any neutral tone you could ever need for an eye look,” Henney says regarding the Makeup by Mario Master Mattes Eye Shadow Palette, making it a no-brainer choice for beginners and experts alike. Inspired by real skin tones the brand has tested on, all 12 shades are easily buildable and blend easily. As for the texture, these luxe powders are super light, creamy, and matte. “I love to do a wash of color with one of the lighter shades and then build the crease and undereye area with a darker tone for a super simple everyday or night look,” Henney discloses.

Bossy Cosmetics Style Meets Substance Eyeshadow Palette

“Move over, boring shades of polite beige and ladylike mauve, the nine rich hues from this reasonably-priced palette can be used to create looks that range from va-va-voom to boardroom,” says Black. “These shadows layer well and are excellent used dry or wet.” Each hue present in Bossy Cosmetics’ Style Meets Substance Eyeshadow Palette is named after cities around the world (like Paris, Mumbai, and Cabo San Lucas) filled with ambitious women.

Gucci Beauté Des Yeux Floral Eyeshadow Palette

This Gucci Beauté Des Yeux Floral Eyeshadow Palette doubles as a piece of ornate decor on your vanity. Open up the floral motif case and you’ll find 12 highly-pigmented, long-wearing shades from a demure matte taupe to a glam, shimmering purple. “It works just as well applied with your fingers as it does with a brush,” says Black. Get creative and play with unique pairings to make it your own. Eye makeup, after all, should be fun.

Meera Beauty Co Melancholia Palette

Blue eye shadow is making a serious comeback right now, according to Mehta, and Meera Beauty Co’s Melancholia Palette is perfect to help achieve that look. This 15-pan palette has “a mix of matte and shimmery shades that compliment every skin tone,” says Mehta. “I love to use these shades with a fluffy brush all over the lid, up towards the brow bone, to create the classic ’90s eye.” Inspired by holiday blues, this palette is dedicated to the toll the holidays can take on mental health. Regardless of the time of year, perhaps the jolly shades of Solace (bright blue), Siren (bright orange), and more will attract good vibes.

Tarte Tartelette 2 In Bloom Clay Eye Shadow Palette

Tarte’s In Bloom Clay Eye Shadow Palette comes packed with 12 matte and shimmery neutral shades that are perfect for doing both casual, everyday looks and bolder or smoky makeup. It scored both a 2020 and 2021 Readers’ Choice Award as it’s a foolproof palette to have in your collection if you fancy creating a wide range of wearable eye looks.

best neutral single eyeshadow

Dior Backstage Eye Shadow Palette in Rosewood Neutrals

Dior’s Backstage Eye Shadow Palettes are staples in runway shows and beauty editors’ kits. This nine-shade palette in Rosewood Neutrals brings muted pinks, plums, and neutral to the table in Dior’s soft and buttery formula for long-lasting wear that seems to naturally blend into your skin.

Beauty Bakerie Do It For The Graham Palette

If you prefer to stick to neutrals but want an easy introduction to colorful eye shadows, Beauty Bakerie’s Do It For The Graham Palette can provide both. The deep red, blue, brown, and gold shades in this palette pack a punch when it comes to pigment, but the shades themselves are just muted enough to remain approachable to beginners.

Charlotte Tilbury Instant Eye Palette in Pillow Talk

Considering the shimmering, buildable payoff of Charlotte Tilbury’s eye shadows, it’s no shocker that this palette has become an instant hit. The Pillow Talk Instant Eye Palette, inspired by her best-selling lipstick shade of the same name, features 12 matte and metallic pink shadows in pink-leaning hues like champagne, rose gold, and magenta.