Do you want to know the best color eyeshadow for the combination of brown eyes and fair skin? We’ve done some research and come up with a list of possibilities for you. This should give you a great starting point for your skin tone and eye color to find the best eyeshadow palette for green eyes and fair skin, what color eyeshadow for brown eyes pale skin, and what makeup looks best with brown eyes.

Whether you are a professional or a beginner, we have tried out all of the top products, researching them for efficiency, and general build quality, taking care to populate the below list with a nice mix of eyeshadow palette for brown eyes and fair skin available at different price points. Generally, we preferred newer models with the high build quality and additional features.

what color eyeshadow for brown eyes pale skin

Scott Barnes Atelier Eyeshadow Palette

J.Lo is one of the greatest brown-eyed beauty muses of our time, so leave it to her go-to makeup artist, Scott Barnes, to create a powerhouse palette perfect for brown peepers.

“This is a gorgeous collection of matte and shimmer tones that offers a wide variety of looks and combinations,” gushes Thomas. The shades in this compact range from frosty lilac and slate blue to deep cobalt, hunter green, and magenta, “smoky tones that really add a sexy edge to brown eyes,” Thomas adds. If you have a cool undertone to your complexion and love a palette with diverse color options, this is a must-have.

Pat McGrath Labs Mothership I: Subliminal Palette

Thomas refers to this as a “classic Pat palette,” and fans of the brand will immediately see why: It boasts a blend of tones, textures, and finishes that McGrath is known for, making it a versatile staple of any makeup kit. “It offers mattes and neutrals that really bring out the flecks in brown eyes,” Thomas says, who notes that the blue shimmer shade will add radiance and spice to any look.

Chanel Les Beiges Healthy Glow Natural Eyeshadow Palette in Deep

“The golds and bronzes in this palette are perfect for bringing out the subtle flecks that make up brown eyes,” says Thomas. “Pair this palette with some warm, neutral mattes to really cover all the bases of tone and texture.”

Tom Ford Soleil Neige Eye Color Quad

“Everything Tom Ford makes is a win for me, and this quad is no exception,” says Thomas. “It’s a beautiful set to create sultry evening looks, or soft daytime looks on any skin tone and fits perfectly into any makeup bag.” Bonus: The two lighter shades can be applied to the high points of the face and blended out for a gorgeous highlight.

Natasha Denona Bronze Eyeshadow Palette

“This palette is a classic,” says Thomas. “You can use it for everything from subtle daytime looks to sexy, smoky nighttime looks.” The molten metallics and creamy mattes in this 15-pan palette skew quite warm, meaning they’ll look best on those with neutral, yellow, and olive undertones, and the colors themselves will seriously stun on medium and deep complexions. Our favorite “secret weapon” in this palette is the shade Deep Dive—while it appears black in the pan, it’s actually a rich eggplant. Try it as an eyeliner for an unexpected color pop.

Huda Beauty Naughty Nude Eyeshadow Palette

“This palette offers a range of soft shimmers and mattes to bring out the subtle tones in brown eyes,” says Thomas. For example, if you have any hazel or green hues in your iris, the pink and purple shades in this compact will compliment them and make them look even greener. The golden iridescence of shades Tantric and Flower Power will also help add extra sparkle to already-bright brown eyes. Even better? The intense pigment of each formula makes them a true-to-color dream on every complexion.

Melt Cosmetics Mary Jane Eyeshadow Palette

If you’re one of those brown-eyed babes who is unfailingly loyal to neutrals, this palette is about to become your new essential. “Every shade is perfect for making brown eyes shine—and the color payoff is stunning,” says Thomas. The 10-pan, cool-toned palette features shimmers, glitters, and mattes ranging from champagne to olive, taupe, and chocolate, and looks especially flattering on light to medium skin tones. Try applying the shimmer formulas with a wet shadow brush for an extra boost of radiance.

Urban Decay Naked Honey Eyeshadow Palette

We’ve tried every Naked palette ever produced—and while we believe the distinction of best palette goes to the original (and sadly, discontinued) Naked palette, Honey is a close second. The opulent shades of gold, caramel, and toffee pick up all those gorgeous golden flecks in a brown iris, making them pop. Try using the matte shades to create a sophisticated, office-ready eye, which you can then easily turn into an evening lewk by adding one of the molten metallic hues on top.

Charlotte Tilbury Starry Eyes to Hypnotise Instant Eyeshadow Palette

If you love the idea of having multiple color story options in one palette but are intimidated by the idea of mixing and matching them yourself, this palette from Charlotte Tilbury is a great investment. It houses twelve shadows divided into four ready-made looks—Happy Glow, Love Glow, Dream Glow, and Seduce Glow—that offer four different color ranges (warm peach neutral, warm rose, cool olive, and cool blue). Each look features a variety of shadow textures and finishes that enhance any complexion. The best part is that the application guesswork has already been solved for you: Each shadow is labeled “prime,” “enhance,” or “smoke” to help guide you and your makeup brush.